Header Ad Module

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Heatpumps, anyone want to comment if this is an decent deal?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #31
    I have read some really stupid/ignorant comments on forums regarding A/C in N.Z......
    Who needs that?
    Costs too much
    Too costly to run....

    Obviously people who have never had it in their homes and are living in cold damp unhealthy houses like so many other N.Zers. Probably the same group of idiots who pack up their families and head off to surfers or Vanuatu every year and then gloat about the big flash holiday. Only to return to their hideous damp houses again for another 12 months. These are the same idiots who would rather do that than spend a small amount of money on a ventilation system to create a nice healthy home. One in which they are comfortable in, there for negating the need to go on a cheap holiday to 'get away' from the nasty weather. Especially if your in a wet area..............
    Ahhhhhhhh rant over, that feels great.

    I spent years living in Australia, and it wasn't until returning back here that I realised how incredibly damp Auckland was. Grabbing a handful of clothes in the wardrobe quickly brought home the fact that we are indeed living in unhealthy homes. Yet there are such a high number of kiwis who just don't realise how damp their living conditions are. Then there is the group of idiots who would rather spend that their money on a flash T.V or Xbox rather than look after their own kids health, some of which are on this forum. These types of people you are never going to get through to.

    The same applies to A/C. There is a group of people who will just never 'get it' Probably people who can't spend that sort of money or people who just don't want to (might ruin their surfers trip this year).

    I have lived in houses without either ventilation or A/C and houses with it. And I will never again live in a house which does not have some kind of regulated air supply.

    Some points I have found with both.

    1) Dry Home; Your first priority is to get a dry home

    A lot of people are getting mislead/confused over this topic. HRV got into a lot of trouble over this particular point.
    But the fact of the matter is, this should be your number one priority, especially living in a wet area like Auckland with High RH levels.
    Your first step to creating a healthier home is creating a dry home. And currently (in my opinion) the most cost effective way of doing that is by use of a PPV (Positive Pressure Ventilation) system. It's an incredibly simple solution containing a fan, ducting, filter, control unit. And for the price of a family trip to surfers, you can have one installed.
    These units are not designed to heat your home, they are designed to force air taken from your roof cavity which is (relative to to your living area) warmer and dryer with a lower RH level, and force into your house. In doing so creating an air exchange and forcing out moister.
    This is the first step in creating your healthy home, and is far more important than installing a heat pump.
    Why have I placed this at the top of my list?
    Because it makes the most impact on your living condition. Of course you should also be thinking about home insulation at this, especially if your thinking of taking the next step and contemplating some form of home heating.
    Fact: Double glazing will not prevent condensation build-up in your home, I know, I've got it. So thinking you've now got your nice new home with DG your sorted......wrong. I would advise you to put some form of ventilation in.
    The longer these units are installed in your home the dryer it becomes. Your clothes, your matress (which can store in the region of 10 litres of water, god knows how much in Auckland), loungesuite, carpet, drapes, everything that is currently storing moister.
    FACT: Dust mites cause hayfever and asthma, they draw in moister through their skin, the dryer your home, the less mites you will have.
    If I were to instal another one of these systems in my new home, I would make sure that I have the vents actually running into the wardrobes and have a vent then going through the wall into the room.

    Overseas they take this form of ventilation so seriously that they factor it in when designing homes and it is added to the equation along side window area/size/layout. But here in good'ol N.Z it's completely unregulated.

    2) Warm Home

    Lets say you have done your best as far as insulation goes and are now looking at heating. A/C; I have used both ducted and wall mounted units and can say that the ducted system is way superior to the simple wall unit. It is moving so much more air.
    An A/C wall unit will heat your air no matter what condition it's in. This is why I placed the PPV system about this. If you have a damp cold home, putting a heat pump in will not solve your problem, in fact it will make it worse, as it will just heat that cold damp air up and turn it into warm damp air. Which would you rather have? The wall unit does have a dehumidifier mode but this is absolutely useless as it just can't move/exchange the volume of air needed to cleanse your home of that damp air. Maybe o.k for bedrooms, but you need to be careful as your body temp needs to drop 1-1.5 degrees? for you to fall into a good deep sleep (someone may be able to expand on that). Was told this by my doctor after having sleeping problems (not associated with A/C).
    FACT: Don't rely on one of those cheap/expensive dehumidifier units that you move around from room to room to sort the problem out either.
    So a heat pump will heat what ever is in your house, damp/dry/cold.
    A ducted system will remove damp air way better than a wall unit and will run way more efficiently as well. It's moving so much more air around your home faster, there for will keep an average controlled temp more effectively than a number of wall units. Put ducts everywherer you possible can. I have them in all bedrooms and in the bathrooms. This helps maintain an entire home. The problem I found with the wall unit is that if you have in one room and then opened the door into another, it would sense this and suddenly crank up to cope with the temp drop. This means it's constantly fighting to keep the temp up/down. As opposed to a ducted system that is keeping an entire house warm, so it doesn't matter how many rooms you are walking in and out of.
    A friend of mine has a total living area nearly half the size of mine yet his power bill is crazy as he runs a couple of those ridiculous electric fan heaters he leaves on in the family/kitchen area.
    I'm not going to say that ducted is the best, as it's not. And in some cases wall mounted may be a good option but unless you are going to go with in-slab water reticlulated system it's about as good as it gets.
    Filters:
    Something I have learned about filters since having my system installed nine months ago. When they install a system be very careful regarding the actual return vent. There are a couple of standard sizes that these come in. Make sure that yours is one of those standard sizes as this will be very important later on if you wish to upgrade to a higher spec filter as I have tried to do. They don't explain this at the time of selling it to you. The standard filter that comes with your unit is crap. It can hardly be called a filter, maybe some sub-grade partial partical filter at best. The next grade filter I went up to is called AFP/3 this is basically a bottom of the line filter material, but it's so much better than the rubbish they give you. If you have gone with a standard size return vent, ask about F7 filters and the availability or them. Don't listen to any bullshit they feed you, if they try to turn you off, get another installer. As this return vent filter is the only one there is and it also protects your unit up in the ceiling as well as filters out dust that will be pumped back into your house via the outlets.
    Installers:
    Make sure that the person who is giving you the quote is the person doing the job. Don't go through a company that gets jobs from sales reps. These guys just walk around selling you systems and then take a commission. I had major problems as the company did not come to inspect prior to the job being stared, which caused serious delays and issues, even after repeated warnings about access from from me via emails and phone calls. And of course never use the phone, always use email and keep all correspondence.

    Sorry for spelling mistakes
    Wow, what an effort for two fingers

    Cheers.

    Comment


    • #32
      Originally posted by iknowyou View Post
      I have read some really stupid/ignorant comments on forums regarding A/C in N.Z......
      Who needs that?
      Costs too much
      Too costly to run....

      Obviously people who have never had it in their homes and are living in cold damp unhealthy houses like so many other N.Zers...
      LOL, I agree with much of your post, just picking up a couple of points.

      So far as I can tell, heat pumps are desirable and wanted by most people. However $3000 is a lot when you can buy a fan heater for $50 so not everyone has the choice.

      I totally agree about our cold damp drafty housing. However our British ancestors thrived in cold damp places for thousands of years without dying off so its not quite as bad as people make out. Keep the living areas warm and chop more wood.

      Comment


      • #33
        Heat-pumps are overrated and overcharged in Kiwiland because of the government subsidies. Sure, a heat-pump is an efficient way of heating, but not the only one.

        Why not solar ventilation by zero running costs, heat distribution systems, wood-burners etc? A friend installed a heat-pump for 15k and on the other hand the Hutt River provides firewood for free?
        I like technology - converted a very cold, damp, mouldy bungalow in a warm and cosy home by insulating, double glazing, solar technology and enjoy it for more than 13 years.

        If a house is too cold (that triggers the condensation) why not start with retaining the heat instead of putting more heat in for Dollars escaping because of the lack of insulation?

        Comment


        • #34
          Originally posted by klauster View Post
          Heat-pumps are overrated and overcharged in Kiwiland because of the government subsidies. Sure, a heat-pump is an efficient way of heating, but not the only one.

          Why not solar ventilation by zero running costs, heat distribution systems, wood-burners etc? A friend installed a heat-pump for 15k and on the other hand the Hutt River provides firewood for free?
          I like technology - converted a very cold, damp, mouldy bungalow in a warm and cosy home by insulating, double glazing, solar technology and enjoy it for more than 13 years.

          If a house is too cold (that triggers the condensation) why not start with retaining the heat instead of putting more heat in for Dollars escaping because of the lack of insulation?
          $15k gets a good ducted central system, certainly more heat than the Hutt River would provide wood for.

          Insulation - easy to insulate under floor and ceiling but the walls - cost a lot more than the cost of an aircon (even the $15k model).

          Solar - my understanding is that to get real benefit from solar you have to design it in from the start. Passive heat sinks etc. Interested to know how much it would cost to insulate, double glaze etc a mouldy bungalow and compare that to the payback time for something else.

          Comment


          • #35
            The reason for the mouldy bungalow needs to be adressed before sticking bandaids over it - roof leak, lack of drainage, underfloor ventilation, cavitys etc.

            Not a fan of heat pumps myself - much rather a fire at least if the worst happens (ie CHCH) you can still heat yourself and cook with out power and power will keep going up as our reliance on it continues.

            How about opening some windows and getting some air circulating?
            Last edited by Maccachic; 15-05-2012, 01:44 PM.

            Comment


            • #36
              Hey klauster
              heat-pump for 15k

              That sounds alot. How many heat pumps did he get for that?

              I've had 3 put in for a total of about $10k.

              Article about heat pumps in this month's Consumer.
              "There's one way to find out if a man is honest-ask him. If he says 'yes,' you know he is a crook." Groucho Marx

              Comment


              • #37
                Originally posted by klauster View Post

                Why not solar ventilation by zero running costs, heat distribution systems, wood-burners etc? A friend installed a heat-pump for 15k and on the other hand the Hutt River provides firewood for free?


                If a house is too cold (that triggers the condensation) why not start with retaining the heat instead of putting more heat in for Dollars escaping because of the lack of insulation?
                Good post Klauster. The first principle of heating is insulation. In a perfect room, your body heat would be enough. Course you'd suffocate. Just sayin.

                However retro insulating isn't always easy requiring time, planning, and effort. Most people just turn another heater on.

                I'm a fan of woodburners and score free wood whenever I can. In fact there are three pine logs the council have just dropped in a park nearby, the Stihl is being sharpened, and I'll whip over there. Even so, there is a bit of work in it sawing, moving, splitting, stacking etc. Frankly there are more and more times (such as this evening) when I just switch the heat pump on and leave the woodburner for the weekend.

                Comment


                • #38
                  when I had a fire I found it anoying - 1st the time spent lighting it then it always had to much heat (a well insulated house doesn't need a lot of heat really). The other night it was a bit chilly so turned on the aircon and nice and cosy. Turned it off after 1hr and it was warm for the rest of the night try that with a fire.

                  Also the aircon keeps me cool in the summer (if we had one it would have anyway). Double bang for my buck.

                  Comment


                  • #39
                    Originally posted by beakernz View Post
                    Not even winter here yet and we have already had several days with indoor temps at 8 degrees. Yes, I've heard on and off burns the most power. I recently installed a wireless energy monitor that will tell us our energy costs per day. It's pretty cool actually. I plugged in our rate and it gives us our running costs based on consumption. So far our normal usage with oil heaters running all night seems around $5 a day. I'm hoping when we move to heatpumps this will be $10 a day or under (if we find a smart way to use them). I would say morning upstairs is turned off, lower floor is turned on to take out the chill. About 11am we turn all pumps off until 5pm then cut lower on again till about 11pm, then bedtime upstairs split system runs in the bedrooms and lower is turned off.
                    BeakerNZ i'd recommend you join Powershop and you will be able to see how much power you use per day. You won't need a wireless energy monitor then

                    Comment


                    • #40
                      Interesting interview on Heat Pumps on National Radio today.

                      According to the scientist David Haywood interviewed they are OK for Auckland, marginal for Wellington/Nelson, and absolutely useless for Christchurch.

                      So I guess this is why Environment Canterbury, the people who are paid to tell you off, are trying to make them compulsory for Christchurch.

                      Comment


                      • #41
                        Well, we're in Dunedin and the pumps have been a real life saver. We have 8.5kw downstairs hall, 8.5kw upstairs hall, 6.5 in the lounge. During the day we run the downstairs on 14-16c and upstairs on 16-17c - at night we run downstairs on 14c and upstairs on 16-17c. It takes the chill out of the entire house and a bit more, our monthly power bill is $250-$350 max. Sure we could set all the pumps on 23c and be sweating but our bill would likely be 7-800 bucks a month. We're not looking to be in t-shirts, just comfortable enough.

                        Comment


                        • #42
                          Also useless in Rotorua because of the amount of sulfur in the air.
                          "There's one way to find out if a man is honest-ask him. If he says 'yes,' you know he is a crook." Groucho Marx

                          Comment


                          • #43
                            Thanks Flyer, that was a good listen, very interesting and knowledgeable.

                            The scientist, David Haywood pointed out the problems heatpumps have in coping with high humidity but cold outside temperatures = most places in the South Island because they are coastal.

                            He advocates pellet fires as the best option. Fair enough but not for me. The pellet fires I've seen are too noisy. Imperfect as it may be, a heatpump plus a logburner is the best answer. If the power goes off, I've still got heat plus a hotplate on the logfire.

                            Comment


                            • #44
                              On what basis did they not work the further south (and therefore colder) you go?

                              Comment


                              • #45
                                My grandparents installed a pellet fire and im not sure if its how they use it but it never seems to put out much heat. The peelets cost them a fair bit too.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X